Creativity/Plot:8/10 The plot was good overall, I loved the woman hiding in the booth a lot.The only thing I didn't like was the end. The fact that Nice Mike got knocked out so quick was kind of irritating since he was supposed to be the big boss battle.
Characterization: 10/10 Petrotasia says you got him perfect, how can I argue with that?
Time and Effort: 4/10 A few spelling errors,(seperately, recongnize, olliged)and a few grammatical mistakes. Remember not to start your sentences with "but", you know that. I once wrote a 7 page tourny entry and that thing was a bitch to edit, so I can only guess that you didn't do a thorough read through of this since you were rushing anyway, but "his arms went like they were on fire" could have been fixed with a good run-through. Also, spell check everything. Twice. Also your tenses got mixed up again and I know I told you about that last time too. I stopped taking points off once I got down to 4/10 left to give you credit for the length, but remember, content is whats important. Also, commas. If you read any of my prose you will see a ton of them chillin, because I find them extremely important. I've already put 11 in this paragraph.
Total:22/30
Creativity/Plot:7/10 The panels with Dani made me laugh a lot, so thanks for that. On the other hand though your plot wasn't as creative. Why was the big epcot ball rolling around?
Characterization: 10/10
Time and Effort: 6/10 (realise,practise) The panel where August bumps into Pyro looked rushed in that... well... there were no faces. At all. Also, the next to last panel looked very rushed, so I docked you a point for that too.
Total:23/30
Winner:
Well... you won by default. But if you want a review like the other two got I will type one up for you.
TIME FOR THE FINAL BATTLE!!!!!!
So, what the hell do we do now? Both of you are cops and you're both good guys so... well...
BATTLE ROYALE! IN ANIMAL KINGDOM!
Kidding.
Actual battle plot: Sonata has been kidnapped again by a man in a swat uniform. August thinks it was Gerald since he is the only cop left on the premises. A fight ensues.
The goal of this fight is to knock your opponent unconscious without killing them and without making it easy (no tapping them on the head with a tonfa and having them go down like a sack-o-potatoes).
Also,Gerald is obviously not responsible for it, it was the chief getting her the hell out of there since she tried to re-enter again.
I know this plot is weak, but I couldn't let the final bout not be of you two battling it out, so this is the best I could come up with. Sorry.
The deadline will be November 15th at midnight.




btw, is it ok if its ok if its a few days late?
--
<insert comment signature here>
--
--------------------------
...wait what?
--
--------------------------
...wait what?
1. My characters hand is part machine gun so is there any proble with that ?
2. Is there any way that she can use her hat instead of the helment?
3. Could I make some modifications to the regular S.W.A.T. gear?
--
STARGATE FANDOM IS A WAY OF LIFE!!!
" Let it be far from the hearts of the faithful to underestimate the power of ones true intellect " ~ Me
2)As long as it isn't used as a weapon (other than beating), then yes.
3) Change in design and color is fine, but if you give her gear strengths you also have to balance those off with weaknesses. Easiest way to do that would be to figure the stronger the armor, the less armor you can wear this way your opponent has more openings.
--
STARGATE FANDOM IS A WAY OF LIFE!!!
" Let it be far from the hearts of the faithful to underestimate the power of ones true intellect " ~ Me
Previous Page123Next Page